The Wisconsin Cheeseman Reviews
The Wisconsin Cheeseman Overview
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
The Wisconsin Cheeseman has a 2.1 star rating from 25 reviews; 33% would recommend. Consumers are mostly dissatisfied: 65% unfavorable, 17% positive. Pros cited: convenient, courteous staff, decent inventory. Cons cited: billing errors, late or missing delivery, and poor customer service.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Read The Wisconsin Cheeseman reviews for delivery and customer service notes.
- Expect potential billing headaches and ask about refunds before ordering.
- Consider alternatives for auto-ship or large orders.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Frequent billing disputes and uncredited payments.
- Late, missing, or incorrect deliveries and poor handling of refunds.
- Customer service issues: long holds, language/communication problems, rude responses.
- Reports of stale or misrepresented food and high price levels.
Positive Feedback
Some customers found helpful, pleasant representatives and acceptable product selection and convenience.
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
The Wisconsin Cheeseman has a 2.1 star rating from 25 reviews; 33% would recommend. Consumers are mostly dissatisfied: 65% unfavorable, 17% positive. Pros cited: convenient, courteous staff, decent inventory. Cons cited: billing errors, late or missing delivery, and poor customer service.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Read The Wisconsin Cheeseman reviews for delivery and customer service notes.
- Expect potential billing headaches and ask about refunds before ordering.
- Consider alternatives for auto-ship or large orders.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Frequent billing disputes and uncredited payments.
- Late, missing, or incorrect deliveries and poor handling of refunds.
- Customer service issues: long holds, language/communication problems, rude responses.
- Reports of stale or misrepresented food and high price levels.
Positive Feedback
Some customers found helpful, pleasant representatives and acceptable product selection and convenience.
Media from reviews
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer
Billing
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
Can't speak with no one in the office. I'm trying to pay my last $50.26, but they added $10!
Preferred solution: Price reduction
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Wilton, Maine
Expensive and not worth the money.
We ordered several things including the cheesecake bits. (Which were stale) Cheese was opened as well as the mustard.
Worst holiday purchase I've ever made. Now I'm stuck paying for food that was tossed into the trash.
User's recommendation: I don't recommend at all.
Brooklyn, New York
Resolved Issue @ post.....
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
I thought the whole experience was quite much ...but on the other hand, it went well...
There was a great chemistry between myself and the worker...which made me feel a great reassurance...
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Scottville, Michigan
Still haven't received the order
- - Questioning if Wisconsin Cheeseman closed since March 2025.
- - Order placed 12/21/25 by phone; promised by 12/24/25; shipping charged.
My Mother - Opal Jean McIntire216 west Ohio Ave Apt 103 Sebring Ohio is the person who paid for the Wisconsin Cheeseman Order and extra shipping charges and the company should give her a full refund . They lied to her and told her that the order would deliver on 12.24.25 and she was charged extra for guaranteed delivery on 12.24.25 today is 12.29.25 and the order still hasn't been delivered.
I was the intended recipient of this order as it was supposed to be a Christmas gift to my husband and I from my Mother but it has not been delivered.
I am concerned that My Mother has been scammed and the money was taken from her checking account . The delivery address for this non received order is - 3010 Pine Acres Trail Hart MI 49420 - RECIPIENT S NAME - TARA AND JESSE ANGEL
My mother placed an order on 12.21.25 via phone call from the Wisconsin Cheeseman website. My mother was told repeatedly that the order/gifts would arrive by 12.24.25 end of day and my mother was charged and paid for expedited shipping to ensure the delivery date. The order has been sitting in New Berlin, Wisconsin FedEx facility since 6 PM on 12.22.25; today is 12.29.25 - still no delivery or explanation and they took my mother's money on 12.21.25.
So...is this a scam site - has Wisconsin Cheeseman actually gone out of business - who took these orders and the money for these orders? Maybe the attorney general should look into this nonsense.
- Get the payment you get nothing
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: Caution - The ORDER never comes.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Knoxville, Tennessee
Terrible company
- - Ordered Dec 2; nothing arrived by 12/24 and a bill was sent and paid.
- - Most items were out of stock after payment.
- - Waiting for a refund and doubts due to misrepresentations.
First time, last time. They say order now, pay on Feb 26.
I ordered on Dec 2, well before the Christmas deadline of Dec 16. Nothing here; it's 12/24. They sent me a bill 2 weeks ago, which I paid in full. Now, out of stock for most of my items, as they didn't send until I paid.
A Christmas tradition ruined. I've always used a competing company and will go back to them. What a mistake.
The woman who answers the phone can barely speak English, and I had to have her repeat things over and over. I'm waiting on a refund check, which I have my doubts about after all these misrepresentations.
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: Stay away.
Richmond, Virginia
Payment
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
A pleasant representative took my info, then switched me to the online payments.
Everything went smoothly
User's recommendation: I recommend this company to anyone who eats cheese, summer sausage, jams, spicy mustard1 etc
Richmond, Indiana
About my bill
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
Never talked to anyone. I paid the bill in December. I got another bill for something I already paid for.
- Convenient
- Having to pay for something twice
Preferred solution: Conv
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Asheboro, North Carolina
I can’t get into my account
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
I ordered from the company last year and wanted to again this year but I cant get into my account, could someone please help me
Preferred solution: I want someone to help me
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Lacey, Washington
Lousy products
Breads crumble and are so small. Cookies taste bland.
Too expensive for what I got, plus high shipping costs. Never again.
- Bad products
Preferred solution: Drop charges on my account
User's recommendation: Stay clear of this place.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Monroe, Wisconsin
I wish I could rate them -10!
- - December corporate gifts order; six months later still unresolved.
- - Invoices doubled due to expedited shipping; credits written off.
Horrible experience from start to now (because we're still not finished). We are going into our 6th month on this.
I ordered some corporate gifts mid-December. The form said to email it in and if paying by credit card, they would call and get a card number. That never happened, so I called customer service. She assured me she would send the order back to fulfillment and they would be calling for a card number within 24 hours.
When that didn't happen for over a week, I placed an order elsewhere. Fast forward to about a week before Christmas when I got a shipping notice that my packages were going out. I called again. I was told that they couldn't stop my order as it was already in the process of shipping, but that I would not be billed for it.
Another week goes by and I get an invoice for almost double the original invoice. They added expedited shipping because they screwed up. I should pay for your mistakes? No.
I called again. Same thing: 'Oh, we see your order was messed up. We will write this off.' At least three times since, I have gotten bills, called in, and got the same run-around. This time, they wrote off all but $37.
Why?! But now, they're charging interest! I emailed the credit department last week and told them for at least the 10th time that we are not paying it. So they wrote off the $1.97 in interest and left the $35.
I would be incredibly embarrassed if I had any affiliation with this company. Absolutely, positively, unequivocally would never, ever do business with them or recommend them to anyone.
- 6 months later my bill is not fixed
- Terrible customer service
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: ABSOLUTELY do NOT order here! Go somewhere else.
Cancel my auto payment
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
I just want to cancel auto pay if I get my bill to pay my bills my money order I was causing cheese man that's one to go with
User's recommendation: Wisconsin cheese man that's one to go with
This review is written by an individual who has purchased the reviewed product/service and/or confirms being a paying customer of this company. Check our FAQ
Verified Buyer |
Lorain, Ohio
Ordered wild sausage and cheese box. Ordered in November. Was charged almost 100.00. Still never been received and it’s January.
- - Ordered in November for Thanksgiving.
- - Shipped to a previous address, not the TX address.
- - Still not received as of January 2, 2025.
- - No refund yet.
I am very disappointed with this company. Ordered cheese and sausage in November to arrive around Thanksgiving.
It was sent to a previous address. I did not give them the previous address. I gave them an address in TX. They sent to FL.
her is is January 2, 2025.
Still not been received. Still no refund!
User's recommendation: Do not buy from this company! They have terrible service. When you call you get the run around. Or you speak to someone who is from another country and hard to understand. I requested a refund and was told I would get one. Then I was told no since order was shipped! It was shipped but never received. Seriously, read the reviews. Wish I had before placing this order. Next stop is better business bureau!!!
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Monroe, Wisconsin
I ordered the old fashioned Christmas candy 2lbs.net wt and didn't have any fruitful flavors, candy was very stale and all them candy's tasted the same like nothing but loads of sugary taste and nasty
- - Candy tasted nasty and incomplete.
- - It was not fruity.
- - The purchase was a waste of time and money; a refund is requested.
- - I won't reorder or recommend.
The candy tasted nasty and didn't have all the pieces described in the picture. I know that every candy should be very fruity tasting, but it was not that way.
My guests were very disappointed with the disgusting, unflavored, non-fruitful taste. It was a waste of time and money. I want my refund back. However, everything else was good, except for the stale, unfruitful, bland, overly sugary taste.
I want my refund back and will not be ordering the old-fashioned Christmas candy mix again.
I will not recommend it to anyone either. It was very embarrassing...
Preferred solution: Full refund
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerTerrible!!!
- - Ordered two different cheeses but received two of the same.
- - Express shipping was paid for but no credit or refund was offered.
Never heard from them.
I placed an order for 2 different cheeses. They sent 2 of the same.
I paid for express shipping so it would arrive before the holiday. My first thought it they should mail the correct cheeses with a return shipping label for the item I'm returning. Nope. I have to return the item at my cost for the shipping.
What about the express shipping? Credit or refund? Nope.
After a call with customer service they determined that a credit for shipping couldn't happen because the cheese...never shipped. WHAT???
I'M LOOKING AT THE CHEESE
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: AVOID AT ALL COST!!!
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerResolved: I've called them over and over to cancel my order won't answer thephone
- - I received a magazine and placed an order.
- - They said the total interest was extremely high and I tried to cancel, but they won't answer my calls.
Company fixed the issue and I have been provided with apology. Personal
I received a magazine from them and made an order. They told me the total interest was extremely high, so I called them back to cancel.
I spoke to someone; they said I needed to call the credit team. Now, they will not answer any of my calls.
Preferred solution: For my order to be cancelled
User's recommendation: Do not use this company
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerThis company sucks
I would never use this company again. I ordered products for my sister for Christmas, only to find out two days before Christmas that they did not have the products.
User's recommendation: Just don't
Brands Related to The Wisconsin Cheeseman
Seventh Avenue
“I no longer have access to the phone number or email address that I used when I ordered my first order...“
Montgomery Ward
“I was approved for credit ordered 2 pair of head phones there were delivered timely and I'm satisfied my...“
The Swiss Colony
“I have a major problem with Swiss Colony. I ordered almost $200 worth of gifts for Christmas from them....“
Midnight Velvet
“I needed to speak to a live representative. The payment went through twice. I forgot my account was on...“
Companies Similar to The Wisconsin Cheeseman
Wisconsin Cheese Mart
Wisconsin Cheese
Castello
Cheese Brothers
Thank You for Your Reply! We are processing your message.
Your comment will appear after moderation